Originally published July 4, 2016
I was laying in bed this week browsing the AsianBeauty page on Reddit, and I came across a Megathread from May. It was a thread of all of the best and worst sheet masks of 2016 (so far). All printed, it was 25 pages of sheet mask recommendations. I was a little overwhelmed. While trying to figure out how to weed through all the data to find the best recommendations it hit me...project! Contrary to what my room looks like, I love to organize. Data or objects. So, for the last few days I have tabulating the best and worst sheet masks from the [Megathread] May 2016 Beast & Worst of Sheet Masks on Reddit's AsianBeauty page (view the thread here).
In tabulating the best and worst sheet masks, I have also tabulated the best and worst companies as mentioned on this thread. I simply counted how many times a company or specific sheet mask ended up on someones best or worst list. So no getting mad and trolling me because your fave brand ended up in my data pool. I do not need anymore SPAM on enlarging my non-existent male parts thankyouverymuch.
This whole sheet mask data haul was purely out of curiosity and is in no way complete or statistically accurate for the AB community as a whole. It is simply the results of my nerdy curiosity. Now, I only used sheet masks listed as "best" or "worst". I left out all the "meh" listings. They would be too much of a question as to which list they go on. And really, who cares which masks are just "ok"? I want to know which ones are awesome and which ones melt your skin off. I also just tabulated the data and did not form any conclusions based on the skin types people listed. And remember, as with anything in Asian Beauty, YMMV!
Here we go!
The worst sheet masks list was a little odd. It was short and listed a lot of brand lines as a whole. I used only masks or lines that had been listed as a "worst" more than once. The thread as a whole had a lot more "best" than "worst"
Worst Sheet Masks
- Anything by Missha (4 votes)
- Missha Cherry Blossom (not included with the above votes) (3 votes)
- Innisfree Hydrogels (3 votes)
- The Face Shop Real Nature Series (3 votes)
- Tony Moly I'm Real Series (3 votes)
- Benton Snail Bee Sheet Mask (2 votes)
Next up are the companies that were mentioned the most on "the worst" side of the thread. For this list I chose companies that had been mentioned more than three times negatively.
Companies Most Mentioned on "The Worst" Side
- Missha (8 votes)
- Innisfree (6 votes)
- The Face Shop (6 votes)
- Tony Moly (5 votes)
- Skinfood (4 votes)
Missha does not really seem to be anyone's favorite. And yet it was one of the first companies I heard of when starting in with Asian Beauty.
And now for the long list...the best sheet masks! Like the worst list, I decided to list all of the sheet masks with three or more positive mentions.
Best Sheet Masks
- Tosowoong Propolis (9 votes)
- Freeset Donkey Milk Healing (8 votes)
- Papa Recipe Bombee Honey Mask (5 votes)
- My Beauty Diary Birds Nest (5 votes)
- Benton High Content Snail Bee (5 votes)
- My Beauty Diary Black Pearl (4 votes)
- LJH Tea Tree (4 votes)
- My Scheming Mandelic Acid (3 votes)
- Mediental Bidanpo Balhyo Heal and Whiten (3 votes)
- Etude House I Need You Vita Complex (3 votes)
- Klair's Moist Soothing (3 votes)
- Tosowoong Green Tea (3 votes)
- Tosowoong Deep Sea Water (3 votes)
As there were a lot more companies listed under the "best" category, I chose to list the companies that had four or more positive mentions on the thread.
Companies Most Mentioned on "The Best" Side
- Tosowoong (20 votes)
- My Beauty Diary (18 votes)
- My Scheming (16 votes)
- Etude House (14 votes)
- Freeset (9 votes)
- L'Herboflore (7 votes)
- Tony Moly (5 votes)
- Benton (5 votes)
- Evercos (5 votes)T
- Lovemore (4 votes)
- Maskingdom (4 votes)
- Mediental (4 votes)
Tosowoong seems to be the clear standout on the best side, with Missha standing out on the worst. What are your best and worst sheet mask choices? Thoughts on the list as a whole?
Labels: Asian Beauty, Etude House, Freeset, Innisfree, Klair's, Korean Beauty, Korean Skincare, LJH, Mediental, Missha, My Beauty Diary, My Scheming, Papa Recipe, sheet masks, Skinfood, The Face Shop, Tony Moly, Tosowoong